On this page
Quick Answer
There are four methods of payment in international trade: cash in advance, letter of credit, documentary collection, and open account. They sit on a single risk ladder, and the ladder runs in opposite directions for the two sides: what is safest for the exporter is riskiest for the importer, and the other way round. Cash in advance is the lowest risk for the exporter and the highest for the buyer; a letter of credit is low risk for both but costs the most in bank fees and paperwork; a documentary collection is the middle ground; open account is the highest risk for the exporter and the cheapest and easiest for the buyer. Choose by the situation — how well you know the buyer, how big the order is, and what happens to your cash flow if the payment is late — not by which method sounds safest in general.
This article explains what the ITA’s Trade Finance Guide and the ICC’s UCP 600 and URC 522 rules say about getting paid on an export. It is not legal advice or banking advice, and it does not tell you which payment term a particular buyer, country, or bank requires. Check the terms for the shipment in front of you with your bank.
The risk ladder
The ITA’s way of putting it is blunt and worth keeping: for exporters, a shipment is a gift to the buyer until payment is received; for importers, a payment is a donation to the exporter until the goods are received. Every payment method is a different answer to that standoff:
| Method | Risk to exporter | Risk to importer | When the exporter is paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash in advance | Lowest | Highest | Before shipment |
| Letter of credit (LC) | Low, if documents comply | Low to medium | When compliant documents are presented |
| Documentary collection (D/C) | Medium | Medium | Against payment (D/P) or acceptance of a time draft (D/A) |
| Open account | Highest | Lowest | 30, 60, or 90 days after shipment |
That table is the whole article in miniature. The rest of it is what each row actually means in practice, and how to choose between them.
Cash in advance: the baseline
With cash in advance, the buyer pays before the goods are shipped. For the exporter it avoids credit risk entirely, because payment is received before ownership of the goods is transferred. For international sales, wire transfers and credit cards are the most commonly used cash-in-advance options. The ITA describes advance payment as the least attractive option to buyers — and that is the whole problem with it: it is easy to demand and hard to win, especially from a buyer who has never worked with you.
Use it for first orders, small orders, and buyers whose credit you cannot check. Do not expect a buyer to accept it once the relationship is established — at that point the buyer will reasonably ask why they should carry all the risk. For the fuller comparison of cash in advance against a letter of credit — payment timing, who owes which documents, and the escrow middle ground — see Cash in Advance vs. a Letter of Credit: A Payment-Timing and Document-Responsibility Worksheet.
Letter of credit: the bank stands behind the buyer
A letter of credit (LC), also called a documentary credit, is a commitment by the buyer’s bank that payment will be made to the exporter, provided the terms and conditions stated in the LC have been met — as verified through the presentation of all required documents. It is one of the most secure instruments available to international traders. Most LCs are issued subject to the ICC’s UCP 600 rules (Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits), which have been the current governing standard since 2007.
The discipline that makes an LC work is also what makes it demanding. Banks deal in documents, not goods: a spelling mismatch between the LC and the shipping documents can lead to a refusal, which is why discrepancy questions are the classic LC trap. The ITA describes letters of credit as labor-intensive and relatively expensive because of bank fees, and recommends trained document preparation and consulting the exporter’s bank before the buyer applies. An LC is not an unconditional promise to pay regardless of the paperwork — it pays against compliant documents, and a non-compliant presentation is a failed presentation until it is corrected and resubmitted.
Use an LC for a large first order, a buyer in a country whose payment risk you cannot judge, or any sale where non-payment would damage your business. Do not use one for small repeat orders with a buyer you trust — the fees and the document work will cost more than the risk they remove.
Documentary collection: the middle ground
A documentary collection (D/C) is used primarily for ocean shipments. The exporter entrusts the collection of payment to its bank (the remitting bank), which sends the documents the buyer needs to the importer’s bank (the collecting bank), with instructions to release the documents to the buyer for payment. Collections are governed by the ICC’s URC 522 rules.
There are two release terms, and they are not the same risk:
- Documents against payment (D/P). The collecting bank releases the shipping documents only when the buyer pays. The buyer cannot claim the goods without the documents, so the exporter keeps control until payment.
- Documents against acceptance (D/A). The collecting bank releases the documents when the buyer accepts a time draft — a promise to pay at a future date, typically 30, 60, or 90 days out. The exporter gives up control of the goods and waits for the money, which is closer to open account than to D/P.
A collection is cheaper and simpler than an LC, and for an established relationship with some trust it is often enough. What it does not give you is a bank’s payment commitment: if the buyer refuses to pay under D/P, or refuses to accept the draft under D/A, the bank’s job is done and the goods are still yours — sitting in a port on the other side of the world. That is the risk to price into the decision.
Open account: cheapest, riskiest, and sometimes right
With an open account transaction, the goods are shipped and delivered before payment is due — in international sales, typically in 30, 60, or 90 days. It is the most advantageous option to the importer in terms of cash flow and cost, and consequently one of the highest-risk options for an exporter. Consignment is a variation of open account in which payment is sent to the exporter only after the goods have been sold by the foreign distributor to the end customer — no defined payment date at all.
Open account is the normal way established trading partners work: it is fast, it costs almost nothing in bank fees, and it lets the buyer sell the goods before paying for them. It is the right choice when the buyer is a long-term, trusted customer, the amounts are manageable, and a late payment would not damage your cash flow. It is the wrong choice for a first order, a buyer you cannot check, or any sale where non-payment would materially damage your cash flow — regardless of how well you know the buyer.
Two mitigants exist if the commercial logic points to open account but the risk does not: export credit insurance, which pays if the buyer defaults, and factoring without recourse, where a factor buys the receivable and takes the non-payment risk. Both cost money and both need arranging before shipment, not after the invoice is overdue.
Choosing: a decision framework
Answer four questions, in this order:
- How well do you know the buyer? First order, or a buyer whose credit you cannot verify → cash in advance or an LC. A buyer with a clean payment history over several orders → a collection, then open account.
- How big is the order, and what happens if it is not paid? If non-payment would damage your cash flow, do not use open account or consignment — and use a confirmed LC if the buyer’s country or bank adds risk of its own.
- How is the shipment moving? Documentary collection is built for ocean shipments, where the documents control release of the goods. For air freight, the goods may arrive before the documents do, which weakens the control a collection relies on. Check the transport document for the shipment in front of you — the ocean bill of lading and the air waybill control release differently, and that difference decides what a collection can actually protect.
- What does the buyer need? A buyer who must sell the goods before paying cannot accept cash in advance, and may not accept an LC either. If the buyer is real and the order is worth winning, the answer is usually to move one step down the risk ladder and buy the protection another way — credit insurance, a confirmed LC, or a D/P collection instead of D/A.
Worked through, the framework usually lands in one place: first order, cash in advance if it is small, LC if it is large; a few clean orders in, D/P collection; a year of clean payment history, open account with credit insurance behind it. The movement down the ladder is the relationship getting cheaper — and that is the point. Payment terms are not a fixed policy; they are a price you pay for trust you have not earned yet, and you should stop paying it once you have.
What can still go wrong
- The LC discrepancy. The most common LC failure is not a buyer who will not pay — it is documents that do not match the credit. Check every document against the LC before presentation, and have your bank pre-check the set.
- The D/A acceptance. Under documents against acceptance, the buyer gets the goods by accepting a draft, not by paying. If the buyer later cannot pay, you hold a piece of paper, not the goods. Treat D/A as unsecured credit, because that is what it is.
- The open-account drift. Open account terms creep: 30 days becomes 60, 60 becomes 90, and nobody renegotiates because the relationship is good. Put the payment term in writing, with a late-payment consequence, before the first shipment — not after the third late one.
- The currency gap. A 90-day open account gap between invoice and payment can produce a meaningful exchange-rate swing. The fix is a multi-currency account or an FX forward contract, arranged before shipment.
For the trade terms that sit alongside the payment term in every quote — FOB, CIF, DAP, DDP, and what each one makes each side pay for — see Before Reusing an Incoterms Reference in an Export Quote: Check the Rule, Named Place, and Edition. For the full document set that supports the payment — invoice, packing list, certificate of origin, and the rest — see the Export Documentation Complete Guide.
FAQ
Which payment method is safest for an exporter?
Cash in advance — payment arrives before shipment, so there is no credit risk. The trade-off is that it is the least attractive option to buyers, so it is usually only workable for first orders and small orders. For larger first orders, a letter of credit is the standard compromise: a bank commits to pay against compliant documents.
What is the difference between a documentary collection and a letter of credit?
A letter of credit is a bank’s commitment to pay, provided the documents comply. A documentary collection is only a bank’s service: the banks pass the documents to the buyer against payment (D/P) or acceptance of a draft (D/A), but no bank guarantees the payment. A collection is cheaper and simpler; an LC is safer.
When should I offer open account terms?
When the buyer is a long-term, trusted customer with a clean payment history, the amounts are manageable, and a late payment would not damage your cash flow. For a first order or a buyer you cannot check, do not offer open account — use cash in advance or a letter of credit instead.
What rules govern letters of credit and documentary collections?
Letters of credit are governed by the ICC’s UCP 600, in force since 2007; documentary collections by the ICC’s URC 522. Both sets of rules are about documents: banks examine the paperwork, not the goods.
Sources
- U.S. International Trade Administration, Trade Finance Guide — “Methods of Payment” (cash in advance, letter of credit, documentary collection, open account; risk to exporter and importer; consignment as a variation of open account). Also “Get Paid and Finance Your Export Transactions: Methods of Payment” (ITA). Checked November 18, 2026. https://www.trade.gov/trade-finance-guide
- ICC, Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600, ICC Publication 600) — in force since 2007; banks deal in documents, not goods; Article 20 (bills of lading). Checked November 18, 2026.
- ICC, Uniform Rules for Collections (URC 522) — documentary collections, D/P and D/A release terms. Checked November 18, 2026.
- Companion article on the site: Cash in Advance vs. a Letter of Credit: A Payment-Timing and Document-Responsibility Worksheet. Checked November 18, 2026.
- Featured image: a contract being signed, Rawpixel (CC0, via Openverse). https://www.rawpixel.com/image/5904897/photo-image-public-domain-hand-person
